Group Review

 

• Quality Ingredients
• Chocolate--preferably dark
• Real vanilla
• Butter not margarine
• Brown sugar

• Appearance
• Mostly round
• Golden color
• Dark color of chips standing out against the golden background
•  Timing
• Warm cookies over cold ones
• Extra ingredients
• No nuts
• Oatmeal is fine
• Raisins not

 Sherena's cookies:  Visually appealing, golden, chocolate was milk chocolate--not highest preference; tasty and happy to have another; no variations--not the main focus; timing--had probably been made last night, but it didn't affect the quality.

Ryan's review of Sherena's cookies

Homemade
Warm out of the oven
Soft
Experiments that work; variations on the norm
Quality ingredients
More than one

Overall, it was good, and I was glad to have it.  I could go down the line, but I'm inclined not to be critical.  It seemed to be homemade and it was soft, so these were good.  They weren't warm out of the oven.  That would be hard to manage; they were probably made last night.  I didn't notice any variations.  It's difficult to evaluate the quality of the ingredients.  The chocolate was a little light brown which made me think it might have not been as chocolatey as possible--but who am I to judge?  On request, I was given more than one.